Skip to main content

Paying admission to attend a wedding?

 shock; woman; white woman

Dear Polite One,

I am originally from California and moved to New York about a year ago. I was invited to the wedding of my cousin who I meet while living in NY. I was not able to attend the bridal shower and must admit that I did not follow proper etiquette (oops!!!) by failing to send a gift despite my absence.

I was going to pick up a wedding gift, but was told by another cousin, who also lives in New York, that in NY, guests apparently don’t give gifts at the wedding.  She said that the registry was only for the use of the bridal shower and that it is customary in NY to give Cash Only.  Additionally, there are no wedding gift tables at the reception.

I was also told that it is customary to give the cost of the dinner plate of the wedding and that I should search the Internet to find out how much the bride and groom are paying for each plate at their wedding. Even more surprising, my cousin explained that if the cost of the plate is $150, I should give a minimum of $300 for me and a guest. As I thought about it, that would mean I’m expected to pay $150 per plate plus an additional $50 to cover the plate with a little extra cash as the wedding gift.

I was told weddings are really expensive in NY, and dinner plates range from $100 - $200 per person.

In California, it is considered rude to try to figure out what the bride and groom paid for the dinner plate. We give gifts from the heart and sometimes purchase from the registry. If a California wedding guest decides to give cash, she gives what she likes, and there is no formula.

To be honest, if it is customary in NY for guests to pay for their dinners, I would prefer not to go to a NY wedding. I don’t want to feel obligated to pay “admission” to be able to attend a wedding or feel that I am being invited to a wedding not to be a part of the beginning of the couple’s new life together but to pay for a party. I prefer to give a gift from the heart.

Totally confused.

Dear Totally Confused,

You are correct that there is a problem right now on our ‘right’ coast. I’m not sure how this trend began, but it is offensive and definitely not proper etiquette. It must be that someone wrote that it was what they did and everyone followed suit.

It is not proper to ask or expect our guests to open their wallets to attend our functions. What is even more interesting to note is that the gift is supposed to be for the wedding not the reception. It is written in every etiquette book that we are supposed to ship the gift to the couple before the wedding.

Yes, we on the west coast tend to bring the gift to the reception. But that is our very small breach of etiquette that usually doesn’t hurt anyone—unless the card is separated from the gift and we don’t know who gave what. That does make writing our thank you notes a bit difficult.

Thank you for writing me. This is exactly what I need on my site to help our east coast brethren understand why this trend is not proper.

Oh, and if you don’t attend the shower, you are not expected to send a gift. This is probably something most people do not know.

Sincerely,

The Polite One

More by The Polite One

To whom to give gifts?

Dissed my gift; wanted cash!

Does a wedding announcement prompt a gift?

Labels:

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Bride Doesn’t Wants Alcohol or Dances at Reception

Dear Polite One, I've always dreamt that my wedding reception would be alcohol and dance-free - except for the first dance of the bride and groom.  When running the idea past a few people they seemed shocked that I've taken out both of these elements and are making me doubt my idea . The wedding will be in the evening, and then dinner. Is there a steadfast rule that there must be alcohol and dance at a wedding?  Isn't a nice dinner enough? And what things could be added to make it fun for the guests? Thank you, Visitor from Yorkton Saskatchewan Dear Yorkton Saskatchewan, People typically expect alcohol with their dinner at evening wedding receptions .  So, it would probably be better if this were held earlier in the day.  Dancing isn’t that important.  However, it is better to skip all dances, rather than just the one dance with you.  That may seem awkward.  The only hard and fast rule is that we, as hosts, offer our guests wha...
Post a Comment
Read more

Do I wear nylons with strappy sandals for a fall evening wedding?

  Dear Polite One, From what I have read on your site, I should wear a cocktail (little black dress or equivalent) to a fall evening wedding at a golf country club.  Do, I need to wear nylons with my strappy sandals? Wedding Newbie in Wisconsin Dear Wedding Newbie in Wisconsin, Bravo on doing your attire homework!  You are absolutely correct about your attire choice.  Nylons aren't nearly as popular or expected due to our love of sandals. Strappy sandals look splendid with nice dresses, even in the winter.  FYI: It is a faux pas to wear nylons with open-toed shoes. Sincerely, The Polite One More by The Polite One How to dress for a wedding as "the second wife"? How to Dress for Formal Wedding in New York ? What to wear to a formal evening wedding in Napa?
Post a Comment
Read more

Anti-Clueless Advice: What to Wear and What Gifts to Give

How to Decode the Dress Code and to Give the Right Gift Many questions I receive as an etiquette consultant are from wedding guests. Guests are especially concerned with what they should wear and what they should give as gifts .   All who contact me are deeply worried about committing any type of faux pas, as many weddings tend to be surrounded by drama these days. For example, one guest shared that the bride called fuming that the gift she shipped to the bride's home was inadequate, so she returned it to the store for cash—true story.     With crazy, hurtful behavior like that, it is no wonder wedding guests are apprehensive about wedding guest protocol. How do we know what to wear to a wedding? Wedding invitations are supposed to help guests understand the formality of a wedding.   Often, this is not the case.   Here is a real-life example: a guest received an invitation of heavy-weight paper indicating a formal wedding, but the location listed was a...
Post a Comment
Read more