Skip to main content

Should the Wedding Gift Cover the Cost of the Plate?

confusion; questions; seeking clarity

Hi Polite One,

I need help. My step-cousin recently married. She is close with my parents, but not so much with me. Not because of anything bad, we just sort of lost touch, we just never see each other. In fact, I only see her once a year at Christmas.

She comes from a wealthy family and her wedding was extremely lavish. I'm guessing minimum $300-$500 per plate. I was invited to the wedding with a guest and was concerned because I barely had the money to attend the wedding (dress, shoes, etc.), let alone give a gift.

My family is all about monetary gifts (always cash or check). My parents were insisting that I needed to cover the cost of my plate which was more than 2 weeks of my pay. I wanted to decline because I couldn't afford to go and was embarrassed. My parents insisted that it was family and that was not an option. I was told to do whatever I needed to do to get a dress, shoes, and cash gift to cover my plate.

Because of the pressure, I responded that I would attend with no guest. I tried my hardest to come up with the money, but it was impossible. My parents were terribly angry and said I still had to go to the wedding and would have to save money and send the gift as soon as I could.

By some sort of divine intervention, my parent's babysitter screwed them over the day of the wedding. I ended up having to stay home and babysit my little brother. At the time I was relieved, but now I am starting to panic. I need to send a gift and soon. I am worried because I RSVP'd YES and then never showed.  They are out the money for my dinner.

The most I can send this week is $150, or I can save for the next three weeks and try to cover my plate. I guess what I'm trying to ask is, what should I do? I'm single, I'm 30 years old, I live with my parents, work part-time, and attend school.  I don't think my cousin even knows that.

Is $150 acceptable? I heard her parents and my parents talking last week about how so and so "only gave $100" or they "couldn't believe how cheap people were for only giving $250."

I don't want to look rude or like a jerk. I'm starting to freak out because it's been over a month since the wedding, and I still haven't given a gift. If I wait to cover the cost of my plate, they might not get my gift for another month or so.

My aunt, uncle, and cousin are genuinely nice people, they're just a little hung up on money. They also don't know me that well because I don't see them often. When I saw my aunt and uncle last week, they were acting a little strange around me.  I don't think they really know what happened. I think they just think I RSVP'd YES, blew them off, and didn't send a gift. 

In your opinion, what should I do? My parents keep saying that I look disrespectful, which makes me feel terrible. I had good intentions; I just didn't have money. I never meant to be rude or disrespect anyone or hurt anyone's feelings.

Sincerely,

Lana Schifano

P.S. I also attended the shower and didn't give a gift. My mom just threw my name on the card from her gift before we got there.  Sorry for the novel :)

Dear Lana,

I'm sorry you are so frazzled, but it is understandable with this sort of pressure.  

It's just so sad that all these people have the same ill-conceived view of correct etiquette. 

There is no entrance fee for guests attending a wedding reception.  There is no rule about covering the cost of your meal.  A wedding reception isn't a restaurant.  If so, then why would the host choose the meal and dictate the cost of it??  Wouldn't a host provide the entire event cost-free? 

This gift-covering-the-cost-of-the-meal rule doesn't make any sense and is extremely unfair to guests.  In fact, why would your parents and your cousin's parents know how much each person gave as a gift?  It shouldn't be common knowledge.  The gifts are for the couple, no one else. 

The wedding is the gift-giving event, not the reception.  Gifts can be anything, not always money—even if that's what is expected or requested (very impolite and presumptuous).  Just because that is how it has always been done in the family doesn't mean it is right.  In this case, it isn't.  But that doesn't help you in this instance.  What to do??

Well, if you have any crafting talent, you could create a needlepoint or decoupage picture of their wedding invitation.  You could give them any gift you want to give.  It doesn't have to be cash and the value doesn't have to be the same as the cost of the plate. 

If your family has a difficult time understanding this or believing it is correct, they can open any etiquette book that covers wedding etiquette. 

I realize there are customs in some regions like this, but it isn't mainstream etiquette.  It isn't proper manners and isn't nice. 

Good luck with this, Lana!!  Please let me know how this plays out for you.

Most sincerely,

The Polite One

More by The Polite One

What to Do When Wedding Guests Invite Guests

Are Charitable Donations an Acceptable Wedding Token?

Ant-Clue 3 Most Asked Wedding Etiquette Questions 

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

4 of the Most Asked Wedding Etiquette Questions Answered

After decades of answering etiquette questions, especially about weddings, I’d like to share a few of those questions that represent the majority of concerns.   Q: Is an invited coworker obligated to spend a certain amount? I'm going to both the wedding shower and the wedding. Should I buy both gifts off the registry? A: Unfortunately, yes. This is one of the biggest reasons I feel that the gift-less wedding shower is the smartest route for us to follow today.  Why should the couple receive more than one gift per guest?  It just doesn't make any sense and isn't fair to guests. Q : Registries feel so impersonal.   Is there any way to make it more personal? A: I honestly can't think of any way to make a registry more personal.  If a couple decides to register, they should choose items from the low end of the price range as well as the bigger ticket items, so the list doesn't appear to be a greed-fest.  Unfortunately, it can have th...

When and Where to Seat and Sit

Playing Musical Chairs With Parents Dear Polite One,   On the day of the wedding when it becomes time to seat the parents of the bride and groom, who sits first and last especially when dealing with stepparents? Me First Dear Me First , We have more parental issues to deal with these days than we did in the past.    In fact, more weddings are encore wedding than first, which reflects this trend.  So, to keep everyone happy and separate, we seat parents in this order:  Groom’s father and stepmother (third row); Bride’s father and stepmother (third row); Groom’s mother and stepfather (first row); Bride’s mother and stepfather (first row).   If everyone is on friendly terms, all parents may sit in the front row in the given order.  The stepparents follow the person escorting parents to their seats.   Sincerely, The Polite One Seating Chart Dilemma Dear Polite One,   I'm working ...

Wedding Etiquette 101: Wedding Gift Etiquette Advice for Guests

  Gift Registries, Cash Gifts, Group Gifts… Oh My! As an etiquette expert, I answer etiquette questions every day.   Many of those concern wedding etiquette, especially when it involves giving gifts.   This isn’t much of a surprise when the latest data provided by Forbes shows that the typical wedding guest spends approximately $673 just for the honor of attending.   Of course, this data includes an expensive mix of lodging and childcare.   However, attending the shower, bachelor, and bachelorette parties contributes much of this sum as well.   Follow along as I share my answers to actual wedding gift etiquette questions. Q : Must I buy the gift from the registry?   The couple registered at a higher-end department store with items such as a $300 espresso machine.   I know the bride loves her mochas, but that’s a bit pricy for me.   If I find the same machine at a discount store, can I purchase it there?   A : There is nothing...